I attempted to sign up my children for swimming lessons this week. And, I would have succeeded except that — out of curiosity —I decided to ask the owner of the gym a question about the forms she gave me to fill out.
The forms had the usual, name, age, address, and telephone number fields followed by four identical spaces for each of the children’s biographical information with a puzzling question: Is the child a US citizen?
I was surprised by the fact that someone would ask this question for swimming lessons. This wasn’t a public pool or a place where kids received funding or free classes, or a government or state run program where this information would be pertinent. No, this was a private swimming club, so I politely asked this lady why they were interested in the children’s citizenship.
Almost immediately, the owner of the aquatic center got very defensive and told me that she had every right to put the question on the form, and that people were way too politically correct and sensitive about these things.
Well, maybe she had a point. Actually two points: Whether we agree with an issue or not, people are more sensitive about race, gender, and sexual orientation. And, as the owner of the establishment and she can pretty much do whatever she wants to, with some limitations.
But, I became irritated when the owner explained that this question was crucial in keeping the clientèle of her establishment up to a certain level. She knowingly looked at me and added, “Do you know what I mean?”
I knew what she meant but refused to acknowledge it, so I asked if non-U.S. citizens could take swimming lessons.
To my shock she responded, “It depends.”
On what? The nation the immigrant actually comes from?
I laughed because I wasn’t sure how to express my annoyance, and before I could say anything else this lady told me that I had no idea what immigrants are doing to this country and how they’re destroying and depleting “our” resources, and that she couldn’t and wouldn’t allow certain people to infiltrate her club.
I informed her that even though I am a U.S. citizen, I am an immigrant myself and won’t “infiltrate” her pool. She did tell me that it would still be ok for me and the kids to use the pool, but I didn’t want to frequent the establishment.
As I left, I saw the club had several signs expressing support for the military and discounts for military families. I wondered if me being a foreigner and a military spouse would make her re-examine her beliefs. Probably not.
I didn’t take this woman’s ranting personally, but I realized how difficult it is to change our minds when we define a person based on a stereotype.
My children didn’t get their swimming lessons, but they did learn that I am a “immgrant” and that the lady at the pool doesn’t like “immigrants.” They concluded that it’s better to look for another pool, one that has slides, waterfalls and giant Disney characters.
6 Comments
Wow…well I guess unless we can all prove that we are Native American..then were all immigrants aren’t we?
Maybe she was on her own personal quest to turn all the “non” US citizens in to the FBI for visa checks..LOL
I feel your pain, I myself am a new immigrant to this country and a military spouse. Granted when I tell the average person that I’m from Canada they laugh and ask me if I caught the 4:15 bus to the US. But what they don’t realize is the discrimination that I receive from prospective employers as well as from places that I have attempted to volunteer. Including Walter Reed Hospital!! My husband and I have worked very hard, had to live apart and spent a LOT of money to do everything the legal way…so it would be nice to be treated like an asset to this country, as I have a lot to give! Just like that lady should have treated you!!
I am a MilSpouse and an immigrant myself, and all I can say about that lady is “WOW!”. I would’ve let her know I am a Proud Military Spouse, proud of the USA and an immigrant and deeply offended by this and turned around.
We have been working very hard, and lots of his hard earned money (including his sweat and tears overseas) to get my status as immigrant in to work towards me becoming a citizen, and are still in between the red tape (ugh!), all because we are doing it the legal way!!! I am an asset to the US Army when it comes to Army Family Readiness (Former FRG Leader), Army Family Team Building Instructor and work volunteerly as Vice-President for an Organization that puts in effort to help Military Families in difficult situations and Troops overseas.
She would’ve certainly heared from me!!!
Wow, I guess it’s more widespread than what I thought!
Great to know that so many foreign born spouses are doing great things both in the civilian and military community!
Ciao
Anita
Sadly, you have to wonder if she’s discriminating any other basis as well, like race, religion, ethnicity, etc. I’m not an immigrant but I definitely agree that her way of thinking is very unfortunate and sad. I would have left too!
American people need to wake up! Our husband’s are out there fighting for their safety,their country, their families, and what do these brave men’s families get in return, NOTHING BUT DISRESPECT!!! As a legal immigrant and military spouse, I have had my share of problems with being an immigrant,to the point of being denied military benefits. I say it’s time for change, we need to be heard, we need to remind, that the very rights which our husband’s are fighting for and might lose their lives over, are the very same rights they want to take away from from these brave men’s families!